Hybrid Manufacturing

The combination of two manufacturing technologies

Hybrid Manufacturing

In the context of metallic 3D printing, hybrid manufacturing means the integrative combination of additive and subtractive manufacturing processes.

The two processes differ in their approach to part manufacturing. While subtractive manufacturing removes material , additive manufacturing creates the workpiece layer by layer.

In the metalworking industry, conventional manufacturing processes such as turning, drilling and milling are the most common. Modern CNC machining centers are used for a high number of parts to be manufactured. With the help of a CAM system, multi-axis CNC machine tools are able to machine the workpiece independently and automatically. All machining steps, including the necessary machine steps such as pallet change, parts handling and tool change, are programmed and simulated in advance to enable efficient processes without collisions.


Advantages of subtractive manufacturing

Subtractive manufacturing processes have advantages over additive manufacturing in terms of surface quality, shape accuracy and process times, especially for large components, with comparatively simple geometries, and for series production.


Advantages of additive manufacturing

However, additive manufacturing is more and more conquering the manufacturing industry due to the possibilities of metallic printing. It is fast and material-saving and therefore more cost-effective than subtractive manufacturing. In addition, complex structures can be implemented (design freedom) and individualized components can be produced economically from batch size 1. Additive technology is particularly popular in the context of rapid prototyping.


Generative manufacturing processes

Additive manufacturing offers a wide range of applications, utilizing various generative manufacturing processes. These include, for example, Laser Powder Bed Fusion (L-PBF) and Laser Metal Deposition (LMD). L-PBF involves the layer-by-layer melting of high-performance metal powders using laser energy to achieve the desired shape. In contrast, LMD involves precise material deposition onto the workpiece using a powder jet and laser beam.

Will subtractive manufacturing be replaced by additive capabilities?

Both manufacturing technologies have their strengths and are superior to their counterpart depending on the series size or stage of product development. The question is therefore not whether one technology will replace the other, but how the two will complement each other now and in the future and break new ground together in the context of hybrid manufacturing. In various areas, hybrid manufacturing systems already exist that are capable of performing additive and subtractive processes in combination without the need for further handling of the components.

How does the process of hybrid manufacturing look like?

We used a combination of additive and subtractive manufacturing to manufacture a workpiece. The goal in manufacturing was to combine the advantages of both manufacturing processes.

Our hybrid manufacturing included the following process steps:

  1. Optimization of the design.
    Often a 3D model is available, but it was created without considering the manufacturing specifications and therefore needs to be redesigned and optimized for additive manufacturing. Siemens NX enables data continuity from design through printing to further machining.
     
  2. Preparation for additive manufacturing
    After optimizing the 3D model, the workpiece was prepared for printing.
     
  3. Printing using the powder bed process
    The data was transferred to the printer and the workpiece was built up layer by layer using the powder bedding process (L-PBF).
     
  4. Post process
    In the post process, the workpiece was inspected and heat treated in order to relieve stresses in the component and set the desired material properties. In addition, depowdering and separation of the workpiece from the build plate were performed.
     
  5. Preparation for subtractive manufacturing
    Another step in the post process is NC programming. In NX CAM, the further machining of the workpiece including the creation of the fixture was programmed, the NC code generated and checked by means of machine simulation.
     
  6. Subtractive finishing
    The NC code was transferred to the machine by means of the postprocessor and the machine could start with the postprocessing.
     
  7. Quality assurance
    Finally, a surface inspection was performed and the workpiece was qualified visually and tactilely.
     
  8. Finished workpiece
    Our workpiece is finished and ready for use.

Hybrid manufacturing opens up completely new possibilities for parts manufacturing. It combines the advantages of additive manufacturing, such as speed, material savings and design freedom, with the advantages of subtractive manufacturing, such as surface quality or dimensional accuracy.

Subscribe to our blog
Tips and news around digital manufacturing.